Sunday, September 13, 2026

EDCP 342 Reading 1

Skemp's article on relational and instrumental understanding elaborates on a basic idea which many of us are familiar with in mathematics: simply being able to 'do' the problems, and properly understanding what they mean. Skemp's analogy with 'faux amis' introduces the idea in a very natural way. 

The first thing that made me pause to reflect was when the initial analogy was drawn between the term 'faux amis' and relational and instrumental understandings. I reflected on the fact that perhaps in assessment, relational and instrumental understandings show up in similar ways, but are very different in nature. The second place I paused was ni the devils advocate section. I had assumed that instrumental understanding may only convenience the student in being an 'easier' way to get through a math class, but I had not considered that there was a case to be made for teachers to teach instrumental understanding. Finally, the idea that practicing different pathways between points in a students schema does not necearilly develop that schema. Not only does a student need to always develop their schema, or relational understanding, but they need to be able to navigate with proficiency and efficiency. Going back to map analogy, a student should know the map of the city relatively well, but also be capable of taking transit or walking or biking to navigate throughout.

I believe that in education we should always be striving for relational understanding over instrumental understanding in mathematics. I believe relational understanding not only lends itself to better learning math in the future, but opens the doors for relational approaches to learning throughout life. 

1 comment:

  1. I like the map analogy here, especially your recognition that understanding the map and being able to navigate efficiently are not necessarily the same thing. Your point about assessment also made me wonder: if relational and instrumental understanding can look similar on an assessment, how might we design tasks that give us better evidence of what students actually understand?

    ReplyDelete

Reflection: Group Micro Teaching

Zoom in to scroll around document!